Skip to content

What’s the best way to exit a disruptive employee?

Most people hand in their notice and work professionally until they leave.

But sometimes they tell colleagues how awful the business is, try to convince others to quit or just refuse to do their job properly because they’ve already mentally checked out.

When this happens, you don’t want to be figuring out what you can legally do while they’re causing problems. You need options that you know will work.

Your options for managing departures

Keep them working normally

  • Works fine if they’re being professional
  • Use when you need a proper handover

Address problems early

  • Have a clear conversation about what needs to change
  • Set expectations for their remaining time
  • Document the conversation

Modify their role if problems continue

  • Remove client contact to prevent damage to relationships
  • Limit system access to protect sensitive information
  • Move them to less sensitive work that minimises disruption
A woman in an office waiving paper around. Colleagues looking frustrated.

Consider garden leave for serious situations

  • They stay employed and get paid, but can’t come in, access systems or contact clients
  • Useful if they have sensitive information or could influence others to leave
  • Requires a garden leave clause in their contract to enforce, but you can always propose it

Pay in lieu of notice for immediate removal

  • End their employment today and pay what they would have earned
  • Gets them out immediately when the situation is too disruptive
  • Requires a specific contract clause to enforce, but you can always suggest it

Get prepared now

You can’t predict who might become difficult during their notice period, but you can control how well you’re prepared to handle it.

The businesses that manage exits smoothly have employment contracts with garden leave and payment in lieu clauses, plus a simple leavers process covering handovers and system access.

Get this sorted now and, when someone’s notice period starts going wrong, you’ll have options instead of just hoping that they behave themselves.

Share this article

Recent blog posts

When an Employee Isn’t Following Instructions: How to Handle It Fairly and Confidently

There could be a whole host of reasons for employee 'bad behaviour'; here's how to uncover the truth and fix the issue.

Read

New Financial Year: Is Your HR Budget Working Hard Enough?

Most businesses wouldn’t dream of running sales or marketing without a clear budget. Yet HR—the function responsible for your people, performance and risk—often ends up operating without the same structure or intention.

Read

April Newsletter

Inside this issue: The Employment Rights Act, What working habits say about your business, GFHR News and your questions answered

Read

How to handle conflict between two employees

When employees aren't getting along the impact on them, their colleagues and your business can be significant. Here's what to do...

Read

Strengthening Organisational Design & HR Function for a Large GP Practice

Client: Large multi‑site GP Practice The Challenge As this GP Practice expanded across several locations,…

Read

Practical Ways to Reward Your Team Without Increasing Your Spend

If you want to build more depth into your reward and recognition, but don't have any budget to spare think about these options...

Read